Building Better Teachers

National Review of
Teacher Preparation Programs

 

NCTQ's standards for rating teacher prep:
The nuts and bolts of building better teachers

Drawing on seven years of research, NCTQ has developed a set of comprehensive standards covering the most important aspects of teacher preparation. These "nuts and bolts" represent the knowledge and skills new teachers need in order to be successful in the classroom. By examining evidence—admissions standards, required course syllabi, textbooks, student teaching policy handbooks, and data showing program outcomes—of what teacher preparation programs are demanding of their teacher candidates, our review will reveal which programs are truly preparing their future teachers for tomorrow's classrooms.

(updated: December 20, 2011)

The talent teachers need

Standard 1: Selectivity

The program selects candidates of high academic caliber using a screen that enables comparison of their academic achievement to that of college-attending peers.
Standard applies to: Elementary, Secondary and Special Education programs.
 

What teachers should know

Standard 2: Early Reading

The program consistently prepares candidates in the essential components of effective reading instruction.
Standard applies to: Elementary and Special Education programs.
 

Standard 3: English Language Learners

The program prepares elementary teacher candidates to teach reading to English language learners.
Standard applies to: Elementary programs.
 

Standard 4: Struggling Readers

The program prepares elementary teacher candidates to teach reading skills to students at risk of reading failure.
Standard applies to: Elementary programs.
 

Standard 5: Elementary Mathematics

The institution provides adequate preparation and practice in the specific mathematics content and methods needed by elementary teachers.
Standard applies to: Elementary and Special Education programs.
 

Standard 6: Elementary Content

The institution prepares teacher candidates with content understanding necessary to teach to the Common Core Standards as well as the full elementary curriculum, and have expertise in a single subject.
Standard applies to: Elementary programs.
 

Standard 7: Middle School Content

The program ensures that middle school teacher candidates know their subjects.
Standard applies to: Secondary programs.
 

Standard 8: High School Content

The program ensures that high school teacher candidates know their subject.
Standard applies to: Secondary programs.
 

Standard 9: Special Education Grade-level Subject Preparation

The program requires special education teacher candidates to know the subjects they are likely to teach.
Standard applies to: Special Education programs.
 

What teachers should be able to do

Standard 10: Classroom Management

The program ensures that teacher candidates learn and practice specific techniques for managing the classroom.
Standard applies to: Elementary and Secondary programs.
 

Standard 11: Practice Planning Instruction

The program requires teacher candidates to design and adjust instruction to enhance the academic performance of all students.
Standard applies to: Elementary and Secondary programs.
 

Standard 12: Measurement

The program requires that teacher candidates gain a thorough overview of student assessment that includes practice analyzing student performance data to drive instruction.
Standard applies to: Elementary and Secondary programs.
 

Standard 13: All Children Can Learn

The program ensures that teacher candidates experience high-performing schools that successfully serve students living in poverty.
Standard applies to: Elementary, Secondary and Special Education programs.
 

Standard 14: Student Teaching

The program ensures that the student teaching experience includes the most essential components for success: a placement that is adequately supervised and attendant to the qualifications of the cooperating teacher.
Standard applies to: Elementary, Secondary and Special Education programs.
 

Standard 15: Secondary Methods

The program requires that high school teacher candidates practice teaching the content of their intended subject areas.
Standard applies to: Secondary programs.
 

Standard 16: Instructional Design

The program ensures that special education teacher candidates practice the development of specially designed instruction to learn how to customize instruction that will address a range of student needs.
Standard applies to: Special Education programs.
 

Outcomes

Standard 17: Outcomes

The institution collects data related to its graduates' performance in the classroom.
Standard applies to: Elementary, Secondary and Special Education programs.
 

Standard 18: Impact on Student Learning

The program's recent graduates meet its state's threshold for impact on student learning.
Standard applies to: Elementary and Secondary programs.